The extra cost of insurance due to taxation

As I have written many times, the impact of being not insured or under insured can be life changing. Today, I had a report from one of our many customers saying that people are abandoning some country towns.
Unlike the Coronavirus, where insurance is not able to respond, if people are fully insured, there is a positive effect on the economy as capital enters the Australian economy via reinsurance payments and the like.
When people are not insured, or have insufficient funds to reinstate, it means that there is an increased burden on government, particularly through an increase in demand on those that lost their business and where their employer failed for social security benefits. There is also an increase in requests for social housing.
Therefore, it makes sense to encourage people to insure and be fully insured. We have incentives to take out life and superannuation insurance and health insurance, but general insurance remains a great source of tax income to government.
Rather than just speak to this, I thought today I would set out in a way that even a primary school student can understand the negative impact that high taxation on general insurance has on the take up of insurance.
I start with a $1,000 base premium which has within a terrorism levy which I will ignore for the sake of this illustration. The taxation rates differ by state but I take New South Wales as it is the biggest state by population and has the highest rates. Having said this, every state gets their pound of flesh from this hidden tax.

There are a great number of taxation rates depending on the class of insurance. I have based this on fire and business interruption insurance for commercial operations, as governments –state and local– tend to tax them heavier as they argue that businesses do not vote. Ignoring the huge benefit they, and particularly SMEs, have for the economy.
Anyone that has done basic economics is taught from day one about the supply and demand curve and how if you increase the price of something, people buy less. It should therefore, be obvious to even the most dim witted that if you increase the cost of insurance by 55% people will purchase less.
Despite the tragic bush fires and storm events in New South Wales we have heard from the Premier that she refuses to put the emergency services levy back on the table for discussion. This is despite New South Wales Treasury supporting in their 2012 White Paper.

Through these taxes, New South Wales is collecting circa $1 billion a year. Nevertheless, we hear that the New South Wales Rural Fire Service is under funded.
As I have been saying for years, we all benefit from well trained and equipped emergency services. We all need to contribute, not just those that insure.
While the stamp duty on this class of insurance is 9% in New South Wales it can be 10% in some states and 11% in South Australia.
This is just one example of even a bigger issue.
For years now, I have come to the belief that Australia is greatly disadvantaged by having three levels of government.
Firstly, we cannot afford as a country of our population to have so many ‘people hanging off the teat’. As a result, we are one of the most heavily taxed countries in the world and a lot of the tax collection has to be done by private enterprise.
Secondly, the complexity of doing business or simply being a law abiding resident is far too great and without doubt, much greater than the benefits we receive in return.
More and more SME business owners are saying that dealing with compliance is forcing them to retire.
Lastly, we see that it creates unnecessary conflict which in turn results duplication at best, and inaction at worst. The derailment that resulted in the loss of two lives this week, was due in part from a conflict between the state and federal organisations control over a national asset.
The obvious level of government to get rid of, is the states.
I end with a quote from John Locke (1632–1704), who is regarded as among the most influential political philosophers of the modern period.

Clearly this is being completely missed by all governments when it comes to risk mitigation for flood, cyclone and bushfire, and the level of taxation most notably on insurance.